Billy Joel will play a surprise concert tonight at the 1,555-capacity Paramount Theater in Huntington, Long Island, according to Newsday. The show — Joel’s first Long Island performance in 11 years — will benefit Long Island Cares. Joel has been rehearsing with his band at the theater for the past week in preparation for a European jaunt and decided on the “spur of the moment” to play the gig. His last Long Island appearance was with Elton John in 2002.